Evidence for Two Facets of Pride in Consumption: Findings from Luxury Brands

Brent McFerran, Simon Fraser University, Canada; Karl Aquino and Jessica L. Tracy, University of British Columbia, Canada

Global demand for luxury goods is strong and rapidly growing, with over $200 billion in annual sales each year. Consumers purchase these goods for a variety of reasons, among them because they convey a sense of status, wealth, and exclusivity to others. Past research also shows that people indeed make rapid inferences about others based on their brand choices, and using products can elicit various feelings on the part of the consumer.

Drawing on recent research in social psychology on pride, researchers at Simon Fraser University and University of British Columbia showed that there are two types (i.e., “facets”) of pride in consumption. This paper demonstrates that the feeling which motivates a desire for luxury purchases (accomplishment, or what is termed “authentic pride”) is very different from the feeling that one derives from displaying those same products (snobbery, or what is called “hubristic pride”). In other words, the same emotion (pride) operates in two different ways. These findings shed new light on why consumers purchase luxury brands, highlighting a paradox: these purchases are sought out of heightened feelings of accomplishment (and not arrogance), but they instead signal arrogance to others (rather than accomplishment). Further, the researchers show that these effects are generally more pronounced for those low in narcissism.

These conclusions were based on the results of seven experiments. In some, participants were asked to recall a luxury brand or a non-luxury brand they own, and the researchers assessed how much of each facet of pride they felt: those who recalled luxury goods felt snobbier (hubristic pride), but not more accomplished (authentic pride), showing the former facet of pride stems from luxury consumption. Another version of the study had other people rate a luxury brand user (or a non-luxury one): people judged the luxury brand consumer as more snobbish, but not more accomplished.

However, in other studies, the researchers gave participants a task designed to make them feel authentic or hubristic pride, or a control task and then assessed their desire to purchase luxury and non-luxury branded items. This time, those who felt accomplished had a higher desire to purchase luxury goods than those who felt hubristic pride, suggesting that feelings of accomplishment are a stronger motivator of luxury consumption than feeling snobbish. In another variant, the researchers also measured how accomplished and snobbish participants chronically felt; higher levels of accomplishment were associated with a higher desire for luxury goods.

Rolex-SubmarinerThis research has implications for companies selling luxury goods, or wish to market products as such. Luxury brands are sometimes positioned in a manner associating them with snobbery, for instance contrasting their wearers with laborers of lower status professions. Others, such as Rolex’s “A crown for every achievement”, suggests its product is a marker of accomplishment. This research shows that although consumers indeed associate luxury goods with both accomplishment and snobbery, the former is more motivating in creating consumer desire.

Beyond purveyors of luxury goods, the growing obsession among some consumers to acquire luxury brands, particularly when they cannot reasonably afford them, is also a concern. For those interested in helping consumers better regulate their expenditures and avoid additional debt, these results speak to the psychological factors that motivate consumers to buy products that may make their lives economically precarious.

Quotes from authors:

 “Pride is one emotion with two distinct facets.”

“What we found most interesting is that the emotion that drives purchases is different from the one that the consumer feels post-purchase.”

 “While people feel snobbish from using luxury goods, a desire to feel or appear snobbish was often not the primary motive. People are also driven to luxury goods because they serve as a reward, but this is not how outsiders view consumers of luxury goods – they see them as snobbish, even if they would desire those same goods themselves following a genuine accomplishment.”

If you’re a member of the media and would like to receive the full paper or more information, please contact elina@myscp.org

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s